On Tuesday (February 26), the United Methodist General Conference rejected a proposal to allow churches to officiate same-sex weddings and ordain LGBTQ clergy, reported The Hill.

The “One Church” proposal, which would’ve allowed a more accepting view of the LGBTQ community, was rejected by a vote of 449-374. Instead, United Methodist delegates voted to push forward the “Traditional” plan, which would require churches to either affirm their opposition to gay marriage and non-celibate LGBTQ clergy by 2021 or be removed from the denomination.

According to USA Today, the Traditional plan passed by a vote of 438-384.

These decisions were made at a special conference held specifically to consider various ways the denomination could address its stance on the LGBTQ community.

Advocates of the One Church proposal argued it would keep the denomination together while the worldview on same-sex relationships was changing. However, many opposed this, threatening to split the second-biggest Protestant denomination in America.

Many more liberal churches with LGBTQ-accepting policies will likely leave the denomination following the decision, Rev. Tom Berlin of Virginia told CNN.

“Many of us have members who are saying they will leave,” Berlin, who is a member of the church’s legislative committee, said. “A virus of conflict will spread.”

The Book of Discipline, which is the highest governing document for the United Methodists, contends that “homosexuality is incompatible with Christian teaching.”

LGBTQ advocacy group GLAAD released a statement condemning the denomination’s decision.

“Church is supposed to be a place of refuge and safety, but that’s not the case for our United Methodist friends right now,” Deacon Ross Murray, Senior Director of Training and Education at GLAAD, said. “This decision is not only out of touch with where a majority of Methodist Americans are today but defies true Christian values of love and justice in favor of isolation, discrimination, and real harm for LGBTQ people and their loved ones.”

One Response

  1. Rev. Paul M. Turner

    The United Methodist Church, is the church I grew up in, it is where I was confirmed and had my first Communion, it is where I receive my initial call to ministry, it is where I preached my first sermon, it where I learned that people were all apart of God’s unconditional love and family. The United (apparently only some are) Methodist Church has shattered my heart and shoved a spear deep into my soul. Although, not for the reason you may think for I have moved past the church’s hypocrisy and lies. My anguish is for those the UMC has cast aside, for those the UMC has shattered their faith and told them they no longer have a church or a place in which they can trust the church to embrace them with the love that is ours because of what Jesus taught, lived and died for. I hope the UMC is happy to be a “traditional” Church in a world that is far from traditional. Come 2021 there will be far fewer UMC congregations. May God have mercy upon your traditions as this day I struggle to find the forgiveness that is required to be a person of the Christian faith. For this day as Jesus did many years ago…I weep.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.